Our congregation is currently served by Interim Lead Pastor Karen Natterstad and Associate Pastor Ann Williams.

Pastor Karen Natterstad began her interim lead pastor position on August 1, 2021.  She is a retired pastor with 30 years of parish ministry experience, having served at three congregations in the Greater Milwaukee Synod: Gethsemane in Racine, Atonement in Muskego and Our Savior’s in Oconomowoc.   Pastor Karen continues to serve the Church through interim ministry. She was at St.John’s in Brookfield in 2018 and Gethsemane in Brookfield in 2020.  She is from Minnesota and is a graduate of Concordia College, Moorhead and Luther Seminary, St. Paul. Karen lives in Pewaukee with her husband, Dean and their black lab, Winnie. Dean is also a pastor serving in interim ministry. They have two married children and four grandchildren. Karen is a quilter, bicyclist, and RV camper.

Pastor Ann Williams

Pastor Ann Williams was installed as Associate Pastor at St. Matthew’s on June 12, 2016. In this part-time position, she is responsible for worship leadership, shared preaching, women’s ministry and visitation. Prior to being called to St. Matthew’s, Pastor Ann served a congregation north of Milwaukee from 2009-2013 and was a campus minister at Regis University in Denver from 2006-2009.

Pastor Ann is a graduate of the Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago and holds an undergraduate degree from Luther College in Decorah, IA. She lives in Waukesha with her husband (also an ELCA pastor) and their two children.

In her spare time, Pastor Ann likes to travel, read, eat chocolate, try out new restaurants, garden and listen to her children laugh.



Our staff is a cohesive group of faithful and dedicated leaders who strive to carry out our mission statement to “Welcome, Nurture, Equip, and Send.”

John Paradowski
Minister of Music, Organist, Director of Youth Choir, Adult Handbell Choirs, and Various Ensembles

John Paradowski has been serving as Minister of Music/Organist at St. Matt’s since 1987, where he oversees a wide range of musical activities including multiple graded choir programs & worship planning. Specifically, John directs the adult handbell choirs, youth choir, and assists with the children’s choirs and various small ensembles. He was awarded the National Religious Music Alliance Award of Distinction “for developing and maintaining one of our nation’s finest worship music programs.”

John starting playing organ for worship when he was eleven years old and hasn’t stopped. He lives in Brookfield, with his husband, Jeff, (who is the Director of Children’s Music Ministries.) In his spare time, you are likely to find John looking for what the next piece of music to learn will be as well as editing videos.

Gretchen Haugse
Youth and Sunday School Ministries

Gretchen Haugse has been in charge of Youth and Sunday School Ministries at St Matt’s since 1998, and serving as Youth Director since 2005.  In these positions, she leads activities for middle and high school youth, including the annual youth mission trip; teaches 9th-grade confirmation; and directs St. Matt’s Sunday School ministry, which includes writing and revising curriculum.  Gretchen also coordinates ministry with our partner congregations, especially Reformation and El Salvador. Prior to this, Gretchen taught high school English, after being a stay-at-home mom.

Gretchen holds a BA in English and History from the University of Wisconsin-Madison and a teaching certificate from the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.  She lives in Wauwatosa and is the proud mother of four grown children: Justin, Kirstin, Kari, and Josh.

In her spare time, you are likely to find Gretchen reading, cooking, and gardening.

Sue Swing
Adult Education, Small Groups, and Volunteer Ministries

Sue Swing has been in charge of Evangelism, Adult Education, and Volunteer Ministries at St Matt’s since 2001. In this position, she is responsible for welcoming and conducting new members classes, planning adult education sessions, small group formation/facilitation, and volunteer recruitment and scheduling. Prior to this, Sue served as the Resident Services Manager at St. Camillus Assisted Living Facility and as Program Director with The Shores Brain Injury Rehabilitation Program.

Sue holds a Master’s degree in Rehabilitation Psychology from the University of Wisconsin-Madison. She lives in New Berlin, with her husband, Barrey, and has two adult children, Monika and Mitchell.

In her spare time, you are likely to find Sue caring for her five pets or fostering a stray, working in the yard, playing tennis, or running.

Julia Murphy
Older Adult Ministries

Julia Murphy began her role as Older Adult Ministries Coordinator in August of 2017. In this role Julia works with the Older Adult Ministries Steering Committee to plan monthly meetings, presentations, meals, and outings for the older adults of St. Matthew’s and their guests.

Julia holds undergraduate degrees from the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee in General Music Education and in Music Therapy, as well as a graduate degree in Adult and Continuing Education.  She lives in Wauwatosa with her husband Peter. She and Peter have two daughters, Meghan and Nora.

In addition to serving the vibrant community of seniors at St. Matthew’s, Julia enjoys teaching a baby/parent music class and keeping the books for the family business. During nice weather you may catch Julia and her brother, Norman, biking around town on their blue tandem bicycle.

David Mohr
Senior Choir Director

David Mohr has been serving as Senior Choir Director at St. Matt’s since 1988. In this position, he is responsible for leading the Senior Choir, which is the adult choir at St. Matthew’s that sings each week during the school year. He is retired from his position in computer sales and, recently, from his role as director of the Lutheran A Cappella Choir of Milwaukee.

Dave holds a bachelor’s degree in music education and a master’s degree in choral conducting from UW-Madison.  He lives in Wauwatosa with his wife, Sonja (who is the Communications Secretary) and dog, Bucky. He is the proud father of three grown children: Chris (Alicia), Katherine, and Kyle.

In his spare time, you are likely to find David working on home projects, playing through music in search of the next choir anthem, or reading a good book.

Jeff Reeves

Director of Children and Youth Music Ministries

Jeff ReevesJeff Reeves has served as Director of Children’s and Youth Handbells since 2006, and Director of Children’s Choirs since 2008. In these positions, he is responsible for coordinating and directing choral and handbell choirs for children in pre-kindergarten through 6th grade. Jeff directs GODSBELLS (4th-6th gr. choir chimes), RIGHTEOUS RINGERS (gr. 7th-12th handbells), and co-directs PRAISE KIDS (K-2 choir) and NEW CREATION (3rd-6th gr. choir). Together, John and Jeff also offer a private piano studio at St. Matt’s.

Since 1990, Jeff has specialized in the field of church music for children. His work in both the music publishing industry and the local church has given him the unique opportunity to understand the needs of children’s choirs within the larger ecumenical community. He is the author of numerous publications including children’s music curriculum materials, teaching articles, as well as choral and handbell works for children of all ages. Outside of St. Matthew’s, Jeff also works as Choral Music Editor for Hal Leonard Corporation.

Jeff holds a Bachelor of Music degree from Oklahoma Baptist University and a Master’s of Church Music degree from Southern Theological Seminary. He lives in Brookfield with his husband, John (who is Minister of Music/Organist.)

In his spare time, you are likely to find Jeff spending time with family and friends and traveling to warm weather destinations!

Amy Dankwardt
Praise Kids Co-Director

Amy Dankwardt has been serving as the Praise Kids Co-Director at St. Matt’s since 2011. In this position, she is responsible for lesson planning and instruction of the Jr. and Sr. Kindergarten section of the Praise Kids. This includes weekly activities, the teaching of songs, and leading the group during church performances.

Amy holds a Master’s degree in Audiology from the University of Minnesota. Outside of St. Matt’s, Amy is the Manager of Audiology Services for Aurora Health Care in the metro Milwaukee area.

She lives in Menomonee Falls, with her husband, John, and two children, Jack and Jameson.  In her spare time, you are likely to find Amy at home reading, gardening or being involved with one of the boys’ sports/activities.

Heide Hughes
New Creation Choir Accompanist

Heide Hughes began her role as New Creation Choir accompanist in September 2012 after moving up from Praise Kids, where she had accompanied for several years before.  In this position, Heide assists with all rehearsals for the children’s choir and the Sunday morning services when they sing, as well as with the New Creation musical.

Heide received her Bachelor of Music Therapy degree from UW-Eau Claire and has been working with seniors and in hospice/end of life for most of her career. She lives in Menomonee Falls with her husband, Robert, and they have been members of St. Matthew’s since 1998.  They have two daughters, Abby and Emily.

In her spare time, you are likely to find Heide reading or supporting her kids’ activities, and spending time with family and friends.

Donna Gardner-Manke
Children’s Minister

Donna Gardner MankeDonna has been serving as the Children’s Minister at St Matt’s since 1997. In this position, she is responsible for Kids for Christ, Disciples of Christ, Vacation Bible School, Family Lenten Time, and other activities involving grade school children. Prior to this, Donna served as Youth Director at two churches in Minneapolis.

Donna holds a bachelor’s degree in Human Science from UW-Oshkosh and a Master of Arts degree from Luther Seminary. She lives in Wauwatosa, with her husband, Pr. Chris Manke, and their three grown children, Averie, Noah and Lilly.

In her spare time, you are likely to find Donna reading, attending children’s activities, or spending time with her extended family and/or friends.

Sonja Mohr
Communications Secretary

Sonja Mohr has been serving as Communications Secretary at St. Matt’s since 1991. In this position, she is responsible for many administrative functions in the church office, as well the writing and assembling of the Sunday bulletins and the Voice newsletter.

Sonja holds a degree in elementary education from UW-Madison.  She lives in Wauwatosa, with her husband, David (who is Senior Choir Director) and a fun-loving dog, Bucky. David and Sonja have two adult children, Katherine and Kyle.

In her spare time, you are likely to find Sonja gardening, cooking, or walking in the neighborhood. Photography has become a more recent hobby.

Bridget Smith
Office Assistant

Bridget Smith has been an Office Assistant at St. Matt’s since December 2021. In this position, she is responsible for typing/running the Sunday order of services, serving as receptionist and supporting the church office ministry and other staff as needed. Prior to working at St. Matt’s, Bridget was the office manager of a small law firm for seven years. Before that, she managed the Third World Handcrafts Shoppe, which was located at Capitol Drive Lutheran Church.

Bridget holds a Bachelor’s degree in Elementary Education from Carroll College (now Carroll University). She and her husband Brian live in New Berlin. They have three daughters who are now young adults; Cassie lives in Madison, Maya lives in the Milwaukee area, and Bella is a student at IUPUI in Indianapolis.

In her spare time, Bridget enjoys all sorts of crafts (including quilting, knitting, and crocheting), reading, and cooking.


Lynne Thomas
Sunday school and Youth Ministries support

Lynne started serving as the Sunday School/Youth Ministry Assistant in 2022. In this position, she is responsible for assisting the Director of Sunday School and Youth Ministries with planning and preparation for all activities both inside and beyond St. Matthew’s. Prior to this, Lynne served as an exhibit design assistant at a children’s museum and an assistant teacher before ‘retiring’ in 2004 to be a stay-at-home mom.

Lynne holds a BA in Psychology from Northwestern University and an MEd in Human Development & Psychology from Harvard University. She lives in Brookfield with her husband, Danny, and their two children, Spencer and Lila.

In her spare time, you are likely to find Lynne working on her house or yard, supporting her children’s many activities, or volunteering in her community.

Al Van Lith
Financial Bookkeeper and Administrator

Al Van Lith began his role as Financial Bookkeeper and Administrator in May 2018.  In this role, Al is responsible for the day-to-day financial activities of the church.  That includes depositing weekly offerings, paying invoices, and producing monthly financial statements for council.  Al also handles the Sunday morning volunteer scheduling.

Al holds a degree in accounting from UW-Milwaukee. Al has worked in various positions throughout the years, including for FIS Global, Dedicated Computing and The Milwaukee Jewish Federation.  In addition, for the past seven years, Al has been on the Board of Directors for the Elmbrook Education Foundation, recently working as their Treasurer.

He lives in Brookfield with his wife of 25 years, Susan.  He has two daughters. Caitlin (married to Zach Tritz) is a St. Olaf graduate and is working at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, MN.  His other daughter, Alia, attends St. Olaf College in Northfield, MN.

In his spare time, you are likely to find Al on the golf course, on the stage, travelling, or enjoying life with family and friends.

Marsha Olson
Cleaning Professional

Marsha Olson began providing her cleaning services in January 2017.

In this position, Marsha cleans all restrooms, removes trash and recyclables from the entire building daily, cleans the main and upper kitchens weekly, dusts and vacuums all areas, and does special periodic projects from everything like cleaning the ovens in the main kitchen to cleaning the outside of all lower level windows.  She also orders all cleaning supplies and paper goods for the restrooms and kitchens.

She lives in Wauwatosa with her husband, Dick, who is retired.  They have two daughters, Joyce and Dena.  Joyce is an RN supervisor living in Menomonee Falls, and Dena lives in Florida and fabricates medical devices.

In her spare time, you are likely to find Marsha working in the flower garden, cooking new recipes, making artificial flower arrangements, or dabbling in her hobby of rearing Monarch butterflies.

Dave Fagerberg
Event Setups and Custodial Assistant

Dave Fagerberg began his role as Event Setups and Custodial Assistant in August 2017. He became a member of St. Matthew’s in December 2010 and is also on the Church Property Committee. When you see Dave working at St. Matthew’s, he will be setting up the many religious and social events and activities scheduled during the busy church calendar year. Dave holds a bachelor’s degree in business/interdisciplinary studies and a master’s degree in business (MBA) from the University of Wisconsin-Parkside. He is a retired manufacturing plant and facilities project engineer/project manager. Dave served in the U.S. Air Force for 6 years active duty and is a retired Captain in the Reserves. He lives in Wauwatosa, and has relatives in Madison, Illinois and Iowa. In his not-so-much spare time, he maintains 3 apartment buildings in Milwaukee for a fellow St. Matthew’s member. Dave enjoys going on the mission trips. He has been to New Orleans, Joplin, Oklahoma City, Minot, and Houston.


Bob Gardner
Custodial Assistant

Bob has been serving as the Custodial Assistant at St. Matt’s since 2000. In this position, he is responsible for maintenance of the floors. Prior to this, Bob served as a business owner.

He lives in Milwaukee, with his wife, Joyce, and is the proud dad of two grown children (Donna Gardner Manke and Patrick). He is also the proud grandfather of six grandchildren and several great-grandchildren. In his spare time, you are likely to find Bob up north fishing, woodworking, or spending time with his family.

Council Leaders

We are blessed with a group of faithful and dedicated people to lead our congregation in its vision and mission. St. Matthew’s Church Council is made up a group of twelve members of the congregation who serve for three years.


St. Matthew’s Church Council 2022

President: Tara Laatsch

Vice President: Diane DuBois

Secretary: Carly Crave

Treasurer: Rob Wedel

Council Members:  Anne DeWitt, Fred Heim, Donald Heinz, Laura Hyland, Carl Johnson, Allan Land, Beth Schulz, Pamela Stokke-Ceci, Michael Wolaver.


St. Matthew’s Annual Report 2021